Rookies 10 of 10 Alex Rodriguez

 

Never been a fan.

Especially now that he's a commentator.

Rookies 9 of 10 Hideo Nomo

 

Went on to be an All-Star, Strikeout Leader, and NL ROY in his first season. 

Added another Strikeout Leader and two no-hitters to an 18-year career.

Rookies 8 of 10 Chipper Jones

Went on to become a HOFer.